Rubric for grading summaries

Criterion

Excellent (5)

Good (4)

Satisfactory (3)

Needs Improvement (2)

Clarity

Clear and easy to understand

Mostly clear, minor confusion

Generally clear, some unclear parts

Several unclear sections

Conciseness

Very concise, no unnecessary details

Mostly concise, few extraneous details

Some unnecessary details present

Many unnecessary details

Relevance

All key points included, highly relevant

Most key points included

Some key points missed

Several key points missed

Accuracy

Highly accurate, no factual errors

Mostly accurate, minor errors

Some inaccuracies

Several inaccuracies