1. Home
  2. Peer Review: Skill-set and Behavior-set Assessment Template

Peer Review

Skill-set and Behavior-set Assessment Template

Reviewed:
Dec 30, 2005 by Business
Bookmark

Ratings

Overall Rating: 3.7 stars
Content Quality: 3.6 stars
Effectiveness: 3.4 stars
Ease of Use: 4.1 stars
Overview:
This site provides a form that may be applied in sales and sales management
courses. It features two 12-item assessment tools: one for skills and one for
behaviors. Space is provided for a self-assessment and a second assessment (the
individual's boss or someone the individual knows). Detailed directions for
completing and scoring the form are provided.
Type of Material:
Reference material.
Recommended Uses:
It would be difficult for undergraduate students to complete the assessment tool
without actual experience. Thus, for undergraduate courses the material might
best be used as an example of an assessment tool for sales and sales management.
Alternatively, for MBA/EMBA classes in which the students have at least some
business experience, the assessment tool could be used for personal development.
The material is for self-evaluation initially and then, after completion of
the self-evaluation, the discussion with a supervisor is
recommended.
Technical Requirements:
Students would need Internet access and an Adobe Reader.
Identify Major Learning Goals:
The primary goal appears to be personal development so students learn which
skills and behavior are relevant to being effective on the job. Ideally, the
student would become more self-aware about their skills (e.g., questioning and
listening, negotiation, etc.) and behaviors (e.g., striving for new skills,
taking personal responsibility).
Target Student Population:
The target audience appears to be marketing or management majors as well as
anyone working in sales and/or sales management.
Prerequisite Knowledge or Skills:
Students would need a basic understanding of sales and sales management,
including the role assessment tools can play in those activities.

Content Quality

Rating:
Strengths:
The module provides a good example of an assessment tool, and provides
directions regarding proper use. It can also be used in several different ways
(e.g., example for undergraduates, personal development for MBAs) as the
material is a good first step to class discussion.
Concerns:
To be effective, more context is needed. The ability to self-assess is always a
problem. Also, the problem of discussing one's strengths and weaknesses with a
superior is huge. It is difficult to admit or even recognize weaknesses and
the problem of the sales manager's ability and willingness to assess
subordinates.

Potential Effectiveness as a Teaching Tool

Rating:
Strengths:
The material provides a concrete example of an assessment tool. As a teaching
tool, the questionnaire is easy and useful. It can also serve as a reference
point for open discussions and a template for a broader discussion. It can also
allow professors to cover all the important facets of performance standards for
someone in the sales profession.

Concerns:
As a teaching tool, it is fairly effective because it is still an exercise with
no emotion attached to the outcome. The concepts addressed should be presented
in the appropriate context as established by the instructor.

Ease of Use for Both Students and Faculty

Rating:
Strengths:
The material is relatively easy to use, particularly if presented as an example
of an assessment tool. If the instructor wishes to use the material for the
purposes of personal development, clear instructions are provided. It would be
easy to use for both students and faculty, with few problems. It could be
incorporated into a "real world" experience by using the template for
evaluation after a joint project with team members.

Concerns:
Students with business experience would find the form more interactive, in that
they could conduct a meaningful assessment of themselves. Undergraduates are
less likely to experience this benefit. In addition, grading by the professor
might prove problematic because of the subjective nature of the data.

Other Issues and Comments:
The skill-set and behavior set assessment document is a useful tool for
highlighting the areas necessary to be a successful manager, in the selling
profession or any profession. Instructors might explore the Business Balls web
site (http://www.businessballs.com) for additional information that might be
useful in establishing the appropriate context for using assessment tools.
Creative Commons:
creative-commonscreative-commons by